Free Consultations Available

Free Consultations Available

State Supreme Court Issues Decision in Cody Marble Case

State Supreme Court Issues Decision in Cody Marble Case

Earlier this year, the Montana Supreme Court heard oral arguments in an appeal filed by Cody Marble, who was convicted of raping another boy when the teens were in a Missoula juvenile detention center in 2002. A little over one year ago, the victim killed himself during a several-hour standoff with Havre police after a traffic stop.

The victim accused Marble of raping him in a shower, and parts of the victim’s testimony were corroborated by other juveniles housed at the facility. Throughout the ordeal, Marble has denied that the offense occurred.

Several years after Marble’s conviction, after a visit from the Montana Innocence Project, the victim recanted his trial testimony, signing a statement that the rape never occurred. However, when pushed by the prosecutor a few months later, he again shifted gears, stating that Marble did force him to have sex against his will.

Marble’s attorney requested postconviction relief, arguing that the victim was not believable, given his changing stories. However, the district judge ruled against Marble, rejecting this argument. The district judge held that Marble had failed to “affirmatively and unquestionably establish” his innocence.

Marble appealed to the Montana Supreme Court, requesting that he be granted a new trial because new evidence, the victim’s changing stories, might lead to a different outcome for him. In essence, Marble is seeking the opportunity to show a jury the different statements presented by the victim.

At the argument, the State’s lawyer argued that before a new trial could be granted, Marble had to show that he “did not commit the offense for which the jury convicted” him. The Supreme Court disagreed, finding that the district court used the wrong standard to evaluate Marble’s request for a new trial. The Court held that Marble should not have been required to establish his innocence “affirmatively and unquestionably.”

Instead, the district court should have considered “whether the ‘newly discovered evidence . . ., if proved and viewed in light of the evidence as a whole[,] would establish that the petitioner did not engage in the criminal conduct.’” Marble v. State (“Marble IV”). This standard was proper because it tracked the language of the applicable law, Montana Code Annotated 46-21-102.

Because the district court used the wrong standard to evaluate Marble’s motion for a new trial, the Supreme Court remanded the case back to the district court, directing the lower court to reconsider Marble’s request under the standard it laid out in its opinion. As a result, Marble may yet get a new trial.

At Tipp & Buley, we have over 55 years of combined experience litigating criminal and civil matters in Western Montana. We believe the rights of criminal defendants must be aggressively guarded, and we’ll fight for you. If you’ve been charged with a serious crime, call us today at 406-812-7634 or complete our Contact form online to set up an appointment.

Contact Us

Get a Free Consultation

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
How Would You Like To Be Contacted?

Practice Areas

More Posts

Missoula Police SUV parked behind sedan on nighttime downtown street

Can Missoula Police Stop You Just for Leaving a Downtown Bar?

When Missoula Police Wait Outside the Bars: What the Law Allows Key Takeaways: Missoula police generally cannot stop you just because you left a downtown bar. Montana law requires particularized suspicion that you have committed, are committing, or are about to commit an offense. Leaving a bar is lawful, so

Read More »
Semi-truck parked in gravel lot with safety cone and worker nearby

What Should a Spoliation Letter Include After a Missoula Truck Accident?

Why Evidence Can Disappear Fast After a Missoula Semi-Truck Crash Key Takeaways: A spoliation letter sent after a Missoula truck accident should name the parties involved, describe the crash, and list every category of evidence the motor carrier must keep. That includes ELD data, engine control module downloads, dashcam footage,

Read More »
Vehicle ignition interlock device mounted on car dashboard near steering wheel

What Happens If You Get a DUI While on Probation in Missoula?

Facing a New DUI Arrest While Already on Probation in Missoula Key Takeaways: A DUI arrest while on probation in Missoula can create two separate cases: a new DUI charge and a probation revocation proceeding. Montana law counts a new criminal offense as a non-compliance violation, so graduated sanctions generally

Read More »